Our Customers Have Booked Almost 5,000,000 Hotel Reservations
     
Check Shelter Island Hotel Rates Near Street Address
Pet Friendly Only
10+ Rooms Kids Free

Hotel Guides > New York > Shelter Island Hotels & Motels

Shelter Island, Long Island, New York – Hotels, Motels

Best Value HotelsMap of Hotels

Shelter Island is located off the eastern end of Long Island. Hotels on Shelter Island are on the northern part of the island in the Shelter Island Heights community.

Shelter Island is accessible only by ferry. Check local ferry schedules before traveling to this area.

Map of Shelter Island Hotels

Zoom in (+) to see restaurants and other attractions near hotels.

 

Best Value Hotels in Shelter Island

Rates shown below are estimates. Click See Rates for actual current rates.

Best value hotels are listed first. These are good hotels that cost less than other good hotels. Based on guest reviews and nightly room rates.

  • Seven on Shelter Island Bed and Breakfast Inn

    Seven Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965

    From $255
    Enter Dates
    Seven on Shelter Island Bed and Breakfast Inn

    Rated Very High
    Upscale, smoke-free bed and breakfast inn Near Peconic River and Shelter Island Country Club
    2 floors, 4 rooms - no elevator
    No swimming pool
    Free WiFi
    Free parking
    Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Nov 2014



  • Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island

    35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965

    From $575
    Enter Dates
    Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island

    Rated Average
    Midscale, full-service, beachfront motel Near Shelter Island Country Club
    2 floors, 20 rooms - no elevator
    Seasonal motel - closed during winter
    No swimming pool
    Restaurant
    Free WiFi
    Free parking
    Pet friendly motel - $150 per stay pet fee. - Oct 2014



Hotels and Motels near Shelter Island

The closest cities with additional hotels are Sag Harbor, East Marion, Bridgehampton, and East Hampton.

    Sag Harbor NY Hotels, Motels – approximately 22 minutes south of Shelter Island. This includes 6 miles of drive time and a 10-minute ferry ride from South Ferry Terminal to North Haven Terminal.

    East Marion NY Hotels, Motels – approximately 24 minutes north of Shelter Island. This includes 6 miles of drive time and a 10-minute ferry ride from North Ferry Terminal to Greenport Terminal.

    Bridgehampton NY Hotels, Motels – approximately 29 minutes south of Shelter Island. This includes 10 miles of drive time and a 10-minute ferry ride from Orcas Island Terminal to Anacortes Terminal.

    East Hampton NY Hotels, Motels – approximately 34 minutes southeast of Shelter Island. This includes 12 miles of drive time and a 10-minute ferry ride from South Ferry Terminal to North Haven Terminal.

  • Why Book Here?
    • No fees
    • Lowest price guarantee
    • Pay at hotel in most cases
    • If you don't like your hotel,
      we'll refund your money.
    • Cash rewards + hotel points too
  • See more reasons
Hotel Guides is Made in USA
Shelter Island Info

Pet-Friendly Hotels in or near Shelter Island

Shelter Island Group Hotel Rates

Map of Shelter Island NY Hotels


Hotels near
Nearby Attractions


Hotels near The Pavilion Old Lyme
   15 miles north
Hotels near Westbrook Tanger Outlet Mall
   16 miles north
Hotels near Clinton Crossing Premium Outlets
   18 miles NW
Hotels near Ocean Beach Park
   21 miles NE
Hotels near Riverhead Tanger Outlet Mall
   22 miles SW
Hotels near New London Union Station
   23 miles NE
Hotels near Coast Guard Academy
   24 miles NE
Hotels near Connecticut College
   25 miles NE
Hotels near New London Naval Submarine Base
   26 miles NE
Hotels near Calverton National Cemetery
   26 miles west
Hotels near Mystic Aquarium
   29 miles NE

Earn Cash Rewards plus Hotel Reward Points

Hotel Tips

Important Hotel Tips

Hotels in
Nearby Cities


Greenport NY Hotels
   2.7 miles NW
East Marion NY Hotels
   4.1 miles north
Southold NY Hotels
   4.6 miles west
Sag Harbor NY Hotels
   5 miles SE
Peconic NY Hotels
   7 miles west
Cutchogue NY Hotels
   9 miles SW
Bridgehampton NY Hotels
   9 miles south
Wainscott NY Hotels
   10 miles SE
Sagaponack NY Hotels
   10 miles south
Mattituck NY Hotels
   11 miles SW
Amagansett NY Hotels
   12 miles SE
Southampton NY Hotels
   13 miles south
Jamesport NY Hotels
   15 miles SW
Old Saybrook CT Hotels
   15 miles north
Hampton Bays NY Hotels
   17 miles SW


Shelter Island Hotels, Motels, Lodging, and Accommodations – Shelter Island, Long Island, New York NY, USA



© 2018 HotelGuides.com, Inc. All rights reserved.

About Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Security | Contact Us
Home - HotelGuides.com US Hotels Canada Hotels Hotels in other countries View, change, or cancel my reservations Customer Service Our Better Business Bureau rating is A+ Hotel Guides is Made in USA


Just a moment while we find

the best deals at the best hotels.



loading