test Shelter Island, NY Hotels & Motels | HotelGuides.com
Our Customers Have Booked Over 5,000,000 Hotel Reservations
     
See Rates for Hotels in or near Shelter Island
 Pet Friendly Only
 

HotelGuides.com > New York > Shelter Island Hotels & Motels

Shelter Island, Long Island, New York – Hotels, Motels


Best Value hotels below are sorted by price – except hotels rated below average are listed at bottom, regardless of price.

Shelter Island is located off eastern Long Island. Hotels on Shelter Island are on the northern part of the island in the Shelter Island Heights community.

Shelter Island is accessible only by ferry. Check local ferry schedules before traveling to this area. There is one beachfront hotel on the island, the Sunset Beach Hotel.

Map of Shelter Island, NY Hotels and Motels
 
 Rates shown below are averages. Click See Rates to view rates for your dates.
  • Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island

    35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965

    Enter Dates
    Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Average
    • Upper-midscale, beachfront motel
    • Near Shelter Island Country Club
    • Seasonal motel - closed during winter
    • No swimming pool
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  3.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 128 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 2.6 miles Harborfront Inn Greenport

    209 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944
    2.6 miles

    Enter Dates
    Harborfront Inn Greenport

    Check In1600
    Check Out1100

    Rated Very High
    • Upscale, smoke-free inn
    • 2 miles from Shelter Island Country Club
    • 2-night to 3-night minimum stay required on weekends
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Exercise room
    • Limited parking costs $20 per night - 1 space per room
  • Pet friendly inn More >
  • Note: This inn charges a resort fee of $25 per night - includes WiFi and continental breakfast.
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 407 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 3.6 miles Sound View Hotel Greenport

    58775 NY 48, Greenport, NY 11944
    3.6 miles

    Enter Dates
    Sound View Hotel Greenport

    Check In1600
    Check Out1100

    Rated High
    • Upscale, smoke-free, beachfront motel
    • 4.5 miles from Shelter Island Country Club
    • Outdoor swimming pool open in summer - exercise room
    • Free continental breakfast
  • Pet friendly motel More >
  • Note: This motel charges a resort fee of $29 per night - includes parking and WiFi.
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 1052 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 5 miles Baron's Cove Inn Sag Harbor

    31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    5 miles

    Enter Dates
    Baron's Cove Inn Sag Harbor

    Check In15 00
    Check Out12 00

    Rated High
    • Upper-midscale, smoke-free, full-service motel
    • Overlooks the harbor
    • Free shuttle to beach
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool - exercise room
    • Free WiFi
  • Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Jun 2017
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 378 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 9 miles Topping Rose House Hotel Bridgehampton

    1 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
    9 miles

    Enter Dates
    Topping Rose House Hotel Bridgehampton

    Check In15 00
    Check Out10 00

    Rated High
    • Upscale, smoke-free, full-service hotel
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool - exercise room
    • Free hot breakfast buffet
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 244 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 11 miles Mill House Inn East Hampton

    31 North Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937
    11 miles

    Enter Dates
    Mill House Inn East Hampton

    Check In15 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Very High
    • Luxury, smoke-free, downtown, bed and breakfast inn
    • 2 miles from East Hampton Main Beach
    • No swimming pool
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Pet friendly bed and breakfast inn More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 371 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 11 miles East Hampton House

    226 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937
    11 miles

    Enter Dates
    East Hampton House

    Check In15 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Average
    • Midscale, smoke-free, highway motel
    • Near downtown East Hampton
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool - exercise room
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Feb 2016
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  3.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 122 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 12 miles Roundtree Hotel Amagansett

    273 Main Street, Amagansett, NY 11930
    12 miles

    Enter Dates
    Roundtree Hotel Amagansett

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Very High
    • Upscale, smoke-free hotel 1 mile from beach
    • Located in Amagansett
    • Cottages - 5 studio to 3-bedrooms
    • No swimming pool
    • Yoga classes available on weekends only
    • Free continental breakfast
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking - 1 space per room
  • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 106 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 13 miles Southampton Inn

    91 Hill Street, Southampton, NY 11968
    13 miles

    Enter Dates
    Southampton Inn

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Average
    • Midscale, smoke-free motel on Long Island
    • 2 miles from Cooper's Beach
    • Free shuttle to Cooper's Beach in summer
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Tennis court
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  3.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 359 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 15 miles Saybrook Point Inn Spa & Marina Old Saybrook

    2 Bridge Street, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    15 miles

    Enter Dates
    Saybrook Point Inn Spa & Marina Old Saybrook

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Very High
    • Upscale, smoke-free, full-service hotel near waterfront
    • No shuttle to Bradley Airport
    • Free shuttle to other attractions within 3-mile radius
    • Indoor swimming pool - outdoor pool - exercise room
    • Full-service spa
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Pet friendly resort More >
  • Most Recent HotelGuides Reviews Read >

    TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 1316 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 16 miles Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook

    1750 Boston Post Road, I-95, Exit 66, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    16 miles

    Enter Dates
    Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook

    Check In14 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Average
    • Cheap, smoke-free hotel near Westbrook Tanger Outlet Mall
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Free continental breakfast
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking - truck parking
  • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • Most Recent HotelGuides Reviews Read >

    TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  3.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 130 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 16 miles Waters Edge Resort & Spa Westbrook

    1525 Boston Post Road, Westbrook, CT 06498
    16 miles

    Enter Dates
    Waters Edge Resort & Spa Westbrook

    Check In15 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Average
    • Upscale, smoke-free, waterfront, full-service hotel
    • Overlooks Long Island Sound
    • Heated indoor swimming poolr> Outdoor pool open in summer
    • Exercise room
    • 3 restaurants - 2 lounges - cafe
    • Full-service spa
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - May 2016
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  3.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 1026 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 16 miles Super 8 Motel Old Saybrook

    37 Spencer Plain Road, I-95, Exit 66, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    16 miles

    Enter Dates
    Super 8 Motel Old Saybrook

    Check In1500
    Check Out1100

    Rated Average
    • Cheap motel
    • Near Westbrook Tanger Outlet Mall
    • Some smoking rooms
    • Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Free continental breakfast
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking - truck parking
  • Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Sep 2016
  • Most Recent HotelGuides Reviews Read >

    TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  3.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 345 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 16 miles Windward Shores Hotel Amagansett

    2062 Montauk Highway, Amagansett, NY 11930
    16 miles

    Enter Dates
    Windward Shores Hotel Amagansett

    Check In15 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated High
    • Midscale, smoke-free, beachfront suites
    • Long sand walkway to beach
    • Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Kitchen in every suite
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Nov 2015
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 95 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 17 miles Quality Inn Old Saybrook

    100 Essex Road, I-95, Exit 69, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    17 miles

    Enter Dates
    Quality Inn Old Saybrook

    Check In0 11
    Check Out0 11

    Rated High
    • Midscale, smoke-free, interstate hotel near I-95 at US 1
    • 3 miles from downtown Old Saybrook
    • Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
    • Free continental breakfast
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking - truck parking
  • Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Dec 2016
  • Most Recent HotelGuides Reviews Read >

    TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 368 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 18 miles Old Lyme Inn

    85 Lyme Street, Old Lyme, CT 06371
    18 miles

    Enter Dates
    Old Lyme Inn

    Check In00 00
    Check Out00 00

    Rated High
    • Midscale, smoke-free bed and breakfast inn
    • In town of Old Lyme near I-95 at US 1
    • No swimming pool
    • Full-service spa
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - May 2017
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 180 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 19 miles Hyatt Place Hotel Riverhead

    451 East Main Street, Riverhead, NY 11901
    19 miles

    Enter Dates
    Hyatt Place Hotel Riverhead

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Very High
    • Upscale, smoke-free hotel near downtown Riverhead
    • 4 miles from Tanger Outlet Mall
    • Heated indoor swimming pool - outdoor pool
    • Exercise room
    • Free hot breakfast buffet
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • Most Recent HotelGuides Reviews Read >

    TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 1338 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 20 miles Preston House & Hotel Riverhead

    428 East Main Street, Riverhead, NY 11901
    20 miles

    Enter Dates
    Preston House & Hotel Riverhead

    Check In15 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Very High
    • Luxury, smoke-free, full-service, downtown hotel
    • Near Long Island Aquarium
    • No swimming pool
    • 24-hour exercise room
    • Free continental breakfast
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 59 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 20 miles Madison Beach Hotel

    94 West Wharf Road, Madison, CT 06443
    20 miles

    Enter Dates
    Madison Beach Hotel

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00

    Rated Very High
    • Upper-upscale, smoke-free, full-service hotel
    • A Curio Collection by Hilton hotel
    • Free shuttle to local attractions
    • No swimming pool
    • Full-service spa
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
  • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • Most Recent HotelGuides Reviews Read >

    TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 1025 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

  • 20 miles Hero Beach Club Hotel Montauk

    626 Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954
    20 miles

    Enter Dates
    Hero Beach Club Hotel Montauk

    Check In1600
    Check Out1100

    Rated Very High
    • Upscale, smoke-free hotel near beach
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool open in summer
  • Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Aug 2019
  • Note: This hotel charges a resort fee of $50 per night - includes parking and WiFi.
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 148 reviews  Read Recent Reviews

Hotels and Motels near Shelter Island

The closest cities with additional hotels are Sag Harbor, East Marion, Bridgehampton, and East Hampton.

    Sag Harbor NY Hotels, Motels – approximately 22 minutes south of Shelter Island. This includes 6 miles of drive time and a 10-minute ferry ride from South Ferry Terminal to North Haven Terminal.

    East Marion NY Hotels, Motels – approximately 24 minutes north of Shelter Island. This includes 6 miles of drive time and a 10-minute ferry ride from North Ferry Terminal to Greenport Terminal.

    Bridgehampton NY Hotels, Motels – approximately 29 minutes south of Shelter Island. This includes 10 miles of drive time and a 10-minute ferry ride from Orcas Island Terminal to Anacortes Terminal.

    East Hampton NY Hotels, Motels – approximately 34 minutes southeast of Shelter Island. This includes 12 miles of drive time and a 10-minute ferry ride from South Ferry Terminal to North Haven Terminal.

  • Why Book Here?
    • We add no fees.
    • Lowest price guarantee
    • Pay at hotel in most cases
    • If you don't like your hotel,
      we'll refund your money.
    • Cash rewards + hotel points too
  • See more reasons
 
Shelter Island Info

Pet Friendly Hotels in or near Shelter Island

Shelter Island Group Hotel Rates

Hotels near Me

Nearby Attractions


Hotels near Peconic Bay Yacht Club   3.1 miles west
Hotels near Bay Street Theatre   5 miles SE
Hotels near Duck Walk Vineyards   6 miles west
Hotels near Pindar Vineyards   7 miles west
Hotels near Bedell Cellars   7 miles west
Hotels near Orient Point Ferry   8 miles NE
Hotels near Wolffer Estate   9 miles south
Hotels near East Hampton Main Beach   11 miles SE
Hotels near Shinnecock Hills Golf Club   13 miles SW
Hotels near The Pavilion Old Lyme   15 miles north
Hotels near Westbrook Tanger Outlet Mall   16 miles north
Hotels near Beachfront Amagansett   17 miles east
Hotels near Boardy Barn   18 miles SW
Hotels near Hammonasset Beach State Park   18 miles NW
Hotels near Clinton Crossing Premium Outlets   18 miles NW

Nearby Cities


Shelter Island Heights NY Hotels   1.4 miles NW
Greenport NY Hotels   2.7 miles NW
East Marion NY Hotels   4.1 miles north
Southold NY Hotels   4.6 miles west
Orient NY Hotels   5 miles north
Sag Harbor NY Hotels   5 miles SE
Peconic NY Hotels   7 miles west
Cutchogue NY Hotels   9 miles SW
Bridgehampton NY Hotels   9 miles south
Wainscott NY Hotels   10 miles SE
Sagaponack NY Hotels   10 miles south
Water Mill NY Hotels   10 miles south
East Hampton NY Hotels   11 miles SE
Mattituck NY Hotels   11 miles SW
Amagansett NY Hotels   12 miles SE
Earn Cash Rewards plus Hotel Reward Points
How Do We Order Hotels?

On place pages like this, we order hotels from lowest cost to highest – except we list low-rated hotels at the bottom of the page.

Most of our competitors order these same hotels in other ways that make them more money.
How Do We Define Motel?

To us, motels are smaller lodgings that have rooms you can enter directly from the parking area.

At hotels, on the other hand, you can enter your room only through a hall inside the building.
Hotel Tips

Important Hotel Tips


Shelter Island Hotels near Me

Shelter Island Hotels, Motels, Lodging, and Accommodations – Shelter Island, Long Island, New York NY, USA

© 2021 HotelGuides.com, Inc. All rights reserved.

About Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Security | Contact Us


Home - HotelGuides.com US Hotels Canada Hotels Hotels in other countries View, change, or cancel my reservations Customer Service Our Better Business Bureau rating is A+ Hotel Guides is Made in USA
Hotel Guides

Just a moment while

we find the best deals

at the best hotels.