Best Value hotels below are sorted by price except hotels rated below average are listed at bottom, regardless of price.
Montauk is located on
eastern Long Island , New York. Hotels are located throughout Montauk, many with views of the water or easy access to the beach. Most of the hotels in Montauk are seasonal and close during the winter.
Zoom in (+) to see interstate exits, restaurants, and other attractions near hotels.
Best Value Hotels in Montauk
Rates shown below are averages. Click See Rates to see rates for your dates.
Best value hotels are listed first. These are good hotels that cost less than other good hotels.
Based on guest reviews and nightly room rates.
Kenny's Tipperary Inn Montauk
432 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY 11954
From $99
Enter Dates
From $99
Rated Very High
Midscale, smoke-free motel near Montauk Harbor
Also near beach
Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly motel
More >
- $125 per stay pet fee. < Less
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:
Based on 716 reviews
Read Recent Reviews
Daunts Albatross Motel
22 South Elmwood Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954
From $109
Enter Dates
From $109
Rated Very High
Midscale, smoke-free motel 2 blocks from beach
Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
Free continental breakfast only in summer
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly motel
More >
- pets allowed in a few rooms - $25 per night pet fee for rooms with queen-sized bed - $50 per night pet fee for rooms with two double beds. < Less
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:
Based on 493 reviews
Read Recent Reviews
Montauk Blue Hotel
108 South Emerson Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954
From $200
Enter Dates
From $200
Rated High
Midscale, smoke-free, beachfront motel
Seasonal hotel - closed during winter
Heated indoor swimming pool
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed.
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:
Based on 419 reviews
Read Recent Reviews
Ruschmeyer's Hotel Montauk
161 Second House Road, Montauk, NY 11945
From $205
Enter Dates
From $205
Rated Average
Luxury, smoke-free cabins on west side of Fort Pond
Near downtown
19 cabins
Seasonal cabins - closed during winter
No swimming pool
Free continental breakfast
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly cabins
More >
- $75 per night fee for each pet. < Less
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:
Based on 9 reviews
Read Recent Reviews
Hero Beach Club Hotel Montauk
626 Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954
From $345
Enter Dates
From $345
Rated Very High
Upscale, smoke-free hotel near beach
Heated outdoor swimming pool open in summer
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed.
Note: This hotel charges a resort fee of $50 per night - includes parking and WiFi.
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:
Based on 117 reviews
Read Recent Reviews
Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina Montauk
32 Star Island Road, Montauk, NY 11954
From $430
Enter Dates
From $430
Rated High
Luxury, smoke-free, full-service, Long Island hotel
Surrounded by Lake Montauk - near Suffolk County Parkland
Seasonal hotel - closed during winter
Free shuttle to local attractions
Indoor swimming pool - outdoor pool - exercise room
Full-service spa
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed.
Note: This hotel charges a resort fee of $55 per night - includes parking and Internet access.
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:
Based on 31 reviews
Read Recent Reviews
Montauk Beach House
55 South Elmwood Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954
From $479
Enter Dates
From $479
Rated High
Upscale, smoke-free hotel 2 blocks from beach
Hotel - single-story, 33 rooms
2 heated outdoor swimming pools
Free continental breakfast available during summer
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed.
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:
Based on 274 reviews
Read Recent Reviews
,YX;IZTIP-HTO,GD;ISPDA-ISP,YX;IZOCB-ISP,WV;MTP77-JFK,PW;14946-ISP,YX;60809-ISP,YX;JFKMH-JFK
Why Book Here?
No fees
Lowest price guarantee
Pay at hotel in most cases
If you don't like your hotel,
we'll refund your money .
Cash rewards + hotel points too
See more reasons
Pet Friendly Hotels in or near Montauk
Montauk Group Hotel Rates
Map of Montauk NY Hotels
Hotels near Montauk Yacht Club 2.5 miles NE
Hotels near Block Island Ferry Montauk 2.7 miles north
Hotels near Wolffer Estate 18 miles west
Hotels near Branford House 20 miles north
Hotels near Ocean Beach Park 20 miles NW
Hotels near Misquamicut State Beach 21 miles north
Hotels near Groton-New London Airport GON 21 miles north
Hotels near Waterfront Mystic 21 miles north
Hotels near Mitchell College 22 miles north
Hotels near New London Union Station 23 miles north
Hotels near Mystic Aquarium 23 miles north
Hotels near Peconic Bay Yacht Club 23 miles west
Hotels near The Pavilion Old Lyme 24 miles NW
Hotels near Coast Guard Academy 24 miles north
Hotels near Connecticut College 25 miles north
East Hampton NY Hotels 13 miles SW
Wainscott NY Hotels 17 miles SW
Sag Harbor NY Hotels 18 miles west
Sagaponack NY Hotels 19 miles SW
Orient NY Hotels 20 miles west
Watch Hill RI Hotels 20 miles north
Stonington CT Hotels 21 miles north
Block Island RI Hotels 21 miles NE
Mystic CT Hotels 22 miles north
Greenport NY Hotels 22 miles west
Water Mill NY Hotels 22 miles west
Groton CT Hotels 23 miles north
Waterford CT Hotels 23 miles NW
New London CT Hotels 23 miles north
Niantic CT Hotels 24 miles NW
On place pages like this, we order hotels from lowest cost to highest except we list low-rated hotels at the bottom of the page.
Most of our competitors order these same hotels in other ways that make them more money.
To us, motels are smaller lodgings that have rooms you can enter directly from the parking area.
At hotels , on the other hand, you can enter your room only through a hall inside the building.