Hotels below are sorted by distance from Fire Island.
Fire Island is a barrier island off the shore of Long Island. It is known for the Fire Island National Seashore and its protected beaches. Visitors can reach the island by ferries originating at Bay Shore, Sayville, and Patchogue.
If you need help finding a hotel that is open, call us at 1-800-916-4526.
Zoom in (+) to see interstate exits, restaurants, and other attractions near hotels.
Hotels closest to Fire Island
Rates shown below are averages. Click See Rates to see rates for your dates.
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Apr 2016 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"Not a good value. The hotel room could've been nicer, and the locks could've been better. The housekeeper knocked on my door 5 times even though I kept saying I didn't want the room serviced.2018-08-13"
Midscale, smoke-free hotel one-half mile from MacArthur Airport
Free shuttle to MacArthur Airport
Free shuttle to other attractions within 2-mile radius
No swimming pool
Exercise room
Free continental breakfast
Free WiFi
Free parking
Free park and fly up to 5 nights only
Pet friendly hotel
More >
- allows pets up to 50 pounds, 2 pets per room - no pet fee. - Jun 2016 < Less Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"Nice room for a great price. The hotel staff was friendly.2020-12-29"
"The room was spacious. All the hotel employees were nice, polite, and professional.2020-04-15"
"Great rates. The hotel was clean, and the staff was friendly and accommodating.2017-09-19"
"A pleasant hotel stay, though the bathroom could use an update. Get to breakfast before 10 AM.2016-09-06"
"Clean, smoke-free hotel near MacArthur Airport and several restaurants. The staff was helpful and friendly. Excellent and economical place to stay.2016-04-25"
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Dec 2016 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"The hotel room was clean, but the AC was too loud and the bathroom was too small. The employees were cordial.2016-09-23"
"A no-frills hotel. The washcloths smelled like mildew. Not much selection at the continental breakfast, and the jelly was so solid that I couldn't spread it on my toast.2016-06-28"
"An inexpensive, clean, no-frills hotel. My non-smoking room smelled like smoke. The hotel staff was stoic. An OK stay.2015-10-13"
"Located in a safe area near restaurants. Good hotel for the price. The room was small but clean and cozy, and the bed was comfortable. Narrow bathroom, but it was adequate. The showerhead could've been nicer.2015-09-01"
"We called to let the hotel know we'd be arriving late and to make sure our non-smoking room would be held. We were assured it would, but when we arrived, the only room available was a smoking room. It smelled horrible. Half the TV channels didn't work. We were only given 2 towels, and when we went to the front desk for more, we were told we'd already gotten enough. The manager finally intervened and made sure we had extra towels. Don't stay here.2015-08-19"
Free shuttle to other attractions within 5-mile radius
Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
Free hot breakfast buffet
Free WiFi
Free parking - truck parking
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Jan 2017 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"Great room. The hotel was clean, and the employees were friendly.2017-05-01"
"My family and I loved staying here. The hotel was peaceful and charming. However, we had a few problems. Our room wasn't cleaned, and we didn't get fresh towels. The staff couldn't recommend a restaurant that suited my taste, and instead handed me a pre-printed list of restaurants.2015-12-20"
Upper-upscale, smoke-free, full-service, Long Island, golf hotel
8 miles northwest of MacArthur Airport
Free shuttle to MacArthur Airport
Heated indoor swimming pool - outdoor pool open in summer
Exercise room
Internet access costs $10 per night
Free parking
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Nov 2015 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"A pleasant experience. The rates were reasonable, and the hotel was clean and luxurious. The room met all my needs, and the bed was comfortable. Friendly, courteous personnel. There was a pool, exercise room, walking trail, and golf course. I highly recommend staying here.2018-05-26"
Upscale, smoke-free hotel 2 miles from Long Island Airport
Free shuttle to Long Island Airport
Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
Free WiFi
Free parking
Free park and fly
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Feb 2015 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"Good, clean hotel. The front desk clerks were professional. There was a 7-Eleven down the street.2019-06-18"
"The hotel breakfast was expensive and not that good.2018-07-17"
"The hotel was too hot, and the AC in my room didn't work properly. A maintenance worker came and said the room would cool off eventually, but it never did. It was impossible to sleep.2018-07-08"
"Good hotel, but it was expensive. Nice room. Breakfast wasn't so great.2018-04-11"
"The bed was comfortable, but the only safe was at the front desk. Breakfast was overpriced. There was a Red Lobster next door to the hotel.2016-09-20"
Upscale, smoke-free, all-suite, extended-stay hotel
On Long Island
7 miles from MacArthur Airport
Free shuttle to MacArthur Airport
Free shuttle to other attractions within 5-mile radius
Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
Free hot breakfast buffet
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly hotel
More >
- $100 per stay pet fee. - Jun 2016 < Less Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"Nice hotel. There were two restaurants and a movie theater right across the street. The carpet in my room felt a bit damp. The staff was pleasant, and breakfast was good. I enjoyed my stay.2015-09-16"
Upper-midscale, smoke-free, full-service, Long Island hotel
Near Hauppauge Industrial Park
Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
Free WiFi
Free parking - truck parking
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Feb 2017 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"The room was filthy, and the carpet was stained. The bathroom had mold. Don't stay at this hotel.2017-10-14"
"Comfortable room, but we didn't get housekeeping service in one of our rooms. Clean towels were provided immediately after we called the front desk. Friendly staff. Our "free breakfast" was only for 1 person, even though we had a double occupancy. We'll definitely stay at this hotel again, but won't be having meals here.2015-11-24"
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - May 2015 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"Decent motel room for the price. But a male employee walked in while my wife was in the bath, and she had to scream 5 times before he left. Management refused to take an incident report, so we filed a police report. Don't stay here.2016-02-28"
"I only got one key card, and had to beg the motel clerk for another one for my wife.2015-06-30"
Upper-midscale, smoke-free, full-service, airport hotel
On Long Island
8 miles from MacArthur Airport
No shuttle to MacArthur Airport
No swimming pool
Exercise room
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Dec 2019 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"Nice hotel and room, but renovations were underway so it smelled like paint. The lobby wasn't available.2019-10-28"
"The hotel room was clean and comfortable, and the employees were kind and accommodating.2017-10-11"
"The check-in clerk had a bit of an attitude, so our first impression wasn't great. We called her on her demeanor, and she did apologize. The other hotel clerk was helpful and pleasant to deal with. The room was clean and sufficient, but don't expect a 4-star experience.2016-06-30"
"The hotel was clean and comfortable. No fridge in the room, and no complimentary breakfast.2015-10-03"
"Terrible hotel room. There was a crack across the ceiling, and it looked like someone spilled something down the wall. Not enough hot water for showers. The only positive was the restaurant. Don't stay here.2015-08-06"
Upper-midscale, smoke-free hotel 9 miles from MacArthur Airport
Free shuttle to MacArthur Airport
Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
Free hot breakfast buffet
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Sep 2015 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"Great experience from start to finish. The hotel was clean, and the staff was friendly and courteous.2019-04-28"
"The room was fine, and the hotel clerk was pleasant. Breakfast wasn't fancy, but it was good enough to start our day. I'd definitely stay here again.2018-11-13"
"An excellent hotel. The rates were fair, and the room was clean and had comfortable beds. Friendly staff and good breakfast with a large selection.2017-11-20"
"Good value. The hotel room was great, and the staff was professional. I'd stay here again.2017-08-30"
"The hotel room and common areas were clean, and wireless Internet was free. The staff was friendly and made check-in easy. Great pool and breakfast. Good place to stay.2017-06-08"
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - May 2016 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"Because of Covid, the pool wasn't open and the service was poor. No one asked if we needed towels, and no one brought them or changed the bedding. We had to go get what we needed. Don't stay at this hotel.2020-07-03"
"The suite wasn't clean. One light by the bed was broken and hanging. The sofa bed was covered with food scraps, and the mattress pad was stained. Find a better hotel.2018-01-08"
"Nice hotel and staff. The room was clean. I enjoyed my stay and recommend it.2017-10-15"
"The room was comfortable, but there was only 1 nightstand. Everything else about the layout was compact but nice. The hotel had a pool and exercise room.2016-01-03"
Midscale, smoke-free, all-suite, extended-stay hotel
On Long Island near Bethpage State Park
0.5 miles from Republic Airport
Free shuttle to Republic Airport
Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
Free continental breakfast
Free WiFi
Free parking
Free park and fly
Pet friendly hotel
More >
- $100 per stay pet fee. - Sep 2019 < Less Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"The hotel was fine, but I was surprised by the poor soundproofing. I talked on the phone with my wife in a normal voice, and the person in the next room started banging on the wall. You'll need a car to get to a restaurant.2019-08-27"
"Convenient to restaurants and major roads. Great hotel with an enclosed dog run and dog treats at the front desk. There was a small airport behind the property, but I had no major noise concerns. The room was clean and spacious, and the clerks, housekeepers, and breakfast attendants were friendly and helpful.2018-06-20"
"The hotel was clean, but breakfast wasn't great.2016-07-06"
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Feb 2015 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"The price was just right. We were so impressed with the hotel lobby; it was just beautiful, and our room was gorgeous. The front desk clerks were helpful, courteous, and friendly. Our only complaint was that the pool water was too hot. This won't stop us from staying again.2016-12-31"
"Nice hotel, but breakfast wasn't included. The ice from the ice machine on the 2nd floor was dirty. Stay somewhere else.2016-09-13"
"Good location. The hotel was clean, and the staff was welcoming and helpful.2016-03-30"
"The employees were great. Relax and enjoy a stay here.2016-03-04"
"The hotel staff greeted us pleasantly and upgraded us to a suite. Decent complimentary breakfast. Good place for an overnight stay.2015-08-21"
Budget, smoke-free, all-suite, extended-stay hotel
Near Adventureland Amusement Park
No swimming pool
Free continental breakfast
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly hotel
More >
- $25 per night fee for each pet - $150 maximum per stay fee for each pet. - Jul 2015 < Less Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"The hotel room smelled moldy and wasn't as clean as it should have been. The kitchenette was outdated and didn't have cookware or dishes. The bedskirt had something sticky on it, and the lounge chair was stained.2019-09-18"
"I had a pleasant 5-day stay at this hotel. Book it.2017-03-21"
"Though the hotel clerk was extremely courteous, understanding, and professional, I was disappointed with my room. It had a disturbing odor. The bedsheets were wrinkled and smelled unclean, which made it hard to sleep. There were dirty towels in the room. I won't stay here again and don't recommend it.2017-03-17"
Upscale, smoke-free, full-service hotel on Long Island
Near Adventureland Amusement Park
Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
Internet access costs $13 per night
Free parking
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Feb 2017 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"The room was unpleasant, and located next to a mechanical room. The noise was unbearable. It was too difficult to regulate the room temperature. There was water under the rug near the bathroom. Don't stay at this hotel.2015-07-16"
Not pet friendly
- no pets allowed. - Oct 2015 Most Recent HotelGuides ReviewsRead >
"A pleasant experience. The hotel was clean and modern, and the staff was attentive and nice. Delicious food at the restaurant, and the patio was gorgeous.2017-06-24"
"Nice hotel. Renovations were underway during our stay. No seating in the room to comfortably watch TV.2017-05-24"
"Close to Huntington Station Mall. Clean room. The bed was comfortable and I slept well. Nice, safe place to stay if you're traveling alone.2015-11-24"
