test

We use cookies to make our website easier for you to use. We do not track you when you leave.

15 Hotels TRULY CLOSEST to Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor | HotelGuides.com
Our Customers Have Booked Over 5,000,000 Hotel Reservations
     
See Rates for Hotels near Bay Street Theater
Address Search
 Pet Friendly Only

The hotels below are listed in order of their distance from Bay Street Theater.


Hotels > US Venues > New York Venues > Hotels near Bay Street Theater

Hotels near Bay Street Theater – Sag Harbor, NY
Address: Bay and Main Streets, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
 

  • 1. Baron's Cove Inn Sag Harbor
    31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 Call Us 0.4 mile
    0.4 mile from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Baron's Cove Inn Sag Harbor

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00
    Rated High
    • Upper-midscale, smoke-free, full-service motel
    • Overlooks the harbor
    • 2 floors, 67 rooms
    • Free shuttle to beach
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool - exercise room
    • Restaurant - lounge
    • Free WiFi
    • Not pet friendly
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 393 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 2. Topping Rose House Hotel Bridgehampton
    1 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY 11932 Call Us 4.5 miles
    4.5 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Topping Rose House Hotel Bridgehampton

    Check In15 00
    Check Out10 00
    Rated High
    • Upscale, smoke-free, full-service hotel
    • 3 floors, 22 rooms - elevator
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool - exercise room
    • Restaurant - lounge
    • Free hot breakfast buffet
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
    • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 294 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 3. Maidstone Hotel East Hampton
    207 Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937 Call Us 5 miles
    5 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Maidstone Hotel East Hampton

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00
    Rated Average
    • Upscale, smoke-free, boutique hotel
    • 1 mile from East Hampton Main Beach
    • 3 floors, 19 rooms - no elevator
    • No swimming pool
    • Restaurant - lounge
    • Restaurant open for breakfast and dinner only
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
    • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  3.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 187 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 4. Pridwin Hotel & Cottages Shelter Island
    81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Call Us 6 miles
    6 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Pridwin Hotel & Cottages Shelter Island

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00
    • Upscale, smoke-free, full-service hotel and cottages
    • 3 miles from Shelter Island Craft Brewery
    • Hotel - 2 floors, 49 rooms - elevator
    • 16 cottages
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool
    • 24-hour exercise room
    • Restaurant - lounge
    • Pet friendly hotel and cottages More >
  • Note: This hotel and cottages charge a resort fee of 5% per night - includes parking and WiFi.

    		•
  • 5. Mill House Inn East Hampton
    31 North Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937 Call Us 6 miles
    6 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Mill House Inn East Hampton

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00
    Rated Very High
    • Luxury, smoke-free, downtown, bed and breakfast inn
    • 2 miles from East Hampton Main Beach
    • 2 floors, 10 rooms and suites - no elevator
    • No swimming pool
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
    • Pet friendly bed and breakfast inn More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 377 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 6. East Hampton House
    226 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937 Call Us 7 miles
    7 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    East Hampton House

    Check In15 00
    Check Out11 00
    Rated Average
    • Midscale, smoke-free, highway motel
    • Near downtown East Hampton
    • 2 floors, 52 rooms - no elevator
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool - exercise room
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
    • Not pet friendly
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  3.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 127 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 7. Journey Hotel East Hampton
    490 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937 Call Us 7 miles
    7 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Journey Hotel East Hampton

    Check In1600
    Check Out1100
    Rated Very High
    • Luxury, smoke-free hotel/motel 1.5 miles from beach
    • Main hotel - 2 floors, 22 rooms and suites
    • No elevator
    • 3 cottages
    • Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Not pet friendly
  • Note: This hotel charges a resort fee of $50 per night - includes parking and WiFi.
    • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 188 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 8. Harborfront Inn Greenport
    209 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944 Call Us 8 miles
    8 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Harborfront Inn Greenport

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00
    Rated Very High
    • Upscale, smoke-free inn
    • 2 miles from Shelter Island Country Club
    • 3 floors, 35 rooms and suites - elevator
    • 2-night to 3-night minimum stay required on weekends
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Exercise room
    • Limited parking costs $27 per night - 1 space per room
    • Pet friendly inn More >
  • Note: This inn charges a resort fee of 9% per night - includes WiFi and continental breakfast.
    • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 458 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 9. Greenporter Hotel Greenport
    326 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944 Call Us 8 miles
    8 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Greenporter Hotel Greenport

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00
    • Upscale, smoke-free, full-service motel
    • 2 floors, 34 rooms and suites
    • Outdoor swimming pool open in summer Exercise room
    • Restaurant - lounge
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
    • Not pet friendly.

  • 10. Roundtree Hotel Amagansett
    273 Main Street, Amagansett, NY 11930 Call Us 8 miles
    8 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Roundtree Hotel Amagansett

    Check In15 00
    Check Out11 00
    Rated Very High
    • Upscale, smoke-free hotel 1 mile from beach
    • Located in Amagansett
    • Hotel - 2 floors, 10 rooms and suites - no elevator
    • Cottages - 5 studio to 3-bedrooms
    • No swimming pool
    • Yoga classes available on weekends only
    • Free continental breakfast
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking - 1 space per room
    • Pet friendly hotel More >
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 114 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 11. Sound View Hotel Greenport
    58775 NY 48, Greenport, NY 11944 Call Us 8 miles
    8 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Sound View Hotel Greenport

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00
    Rated High
    • Upscale, smoke-free, beachfront motel
    • 4.5 miles from Shelter Island Country Club
    • 3 buildings - 1, 2, and 2 floors, 55 rooms - no elevator
    • Outdoor swimming pool open in summer Exercise room
    • Free continental breakfast
    • Parking costs $23 per night
    • Pet friendly motel More >
  • Note: This motel charges a resort fee of 9% per night - includes WiFi.
    • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 1145 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 12. Windward Shores Hotel Amagansett
    2062 Montauk Highway, Amagansett, NY 11930 Call Us 13 miles
    13 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Windward Shores Hotel Amagansett

    Check In15 00
    Check Out11 00
    Rated High
    • Midscale, smoke-free, beachfront suites
    • Long sand walkway to beach
    • 2 floors, 35 studio and 2-bedroom suites
    • Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Kitchen in every suite
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
    • Not pet friendly
  • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.0 of 5 stars
    Based on 98 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 13. Hero Beach Club Hotel Montauk
    626 Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954 Call Us 18 miles
    18 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Hero Beach Club Hotel Montauk

    Check In1600
    Check Out1100
    Rated Very High
    • Upscale, smoke-free hotel near beach
    • 2 floors, 30 rooms and suites - no elevator
    • Heated outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Not pet friendly
  • Note: This hotel charges a resort fee of $50 per night - includes parking and WiFi.
    • TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:  4.5 of 5 stars
    Based on 184 reviews 
    Read Recent Reviews
  • 14. Sunset Hotel Montauk
    540 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY 11954 Call Us 19 miles
    19 miles from Bay Street Theater

    Enter
    Dates
    Sunset Hotel Montauk

    Check In16 00
    Check Out11 00
    • Upscale, smoke-free motel near Lake Montauk
    • 2 buildings; single-story and 2 floors, 34 rooms and suites
    • No elevator
    • Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
    • Free WiFi
    • Free parking
    • Pet friendly motel More >

The best thing about using HotelGuides was that I didn't have to pay for my stay in advance, yet I was able to get the best rate.

- Carol Villano
  • Why Book Here?
    • Pay at hotel
    • Live Agents
    • Lowest price
    • All Room Types Available
    • Group Rates
  • See more reasons
Sag Harbor Info

Bay Street Theater

Sag Harbor Hotels and Reviews

Sag Harbor Group Hotel Rates

Nearby Attractions

Hotels near Wolffer Estate   4.1 miles south
Hotels near East Hampton Main Beach   7 miles SE
Hotels near Peconic Bay Yacht Club   7 miles NW
Hotels near Raphael Vineyard   9 miles west
Hotels near Orient Beach State Park   9 miles north
Hotels near Pindar Vineyards   9 miles west
Hotels near Bedell Cellars   9 miles west
Hotels near Shinnecock Hills Golf Club   11 miles SW
Hotels near Orient Point Ferry   11 miles north
Hotels near Orient Point   11 miles north
Hotels near Beachfront Amagansett   14 miles east
Hotels near Hither Hills State Park   15 miles east
Hotels near RGNY Winery   15 miles west
Hotels near Boardy Barn   16 miles SW
Hotels near Vineyards at Aquebogue   17 miles west


How Do We Order Hotels?

We order the hotels on this page by how close they are to this attraction.

Most of our competitors order these same hotels in other ways that make them more money.
How Do We Define Motel?

To us, motels are smaller lodgings that have rooms you can enter directly from the parking area.

At hotels, on the other hand, you can enter your room only through a hall inside the building. Book Group Reservations
Hotel Booking Tips
  1. Beware of non-refundable reservations that could cost you a lot of money if you change or cancel them. +Non-refundable reservations are a gamble that will usually save you less than $10. If you make a $90 non-refundable reservation instead of a $100 refundable booking, you are betting $90 to win $10. Would you do that in Las Vegas?
  2. Don't assume you can cancel a non-refundable reservation without penalty if you notify the hotel weeks or even months in advance. +Often you cannot – because some hotels' profit strategy is to get paid more than once for the same room for the same night.
  3. Always read cancellation policies carefully before you make a reservation. + When is the latest date and time you can cancel without penalty?
    More >
  4. When you make a reservation, you will receive a confirmation email. Take a copy with you to the hotel.
  5. The earlier in the afternoon you check into a hotel, the more likely you will get a room or suite that matches your preferences.



Address: Bay and Main Streets, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 Hotels, Motels, Lodging, and Accommodations near Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor, New York NY, USA

© 2025 HotelGuides.com, Inc. All rights reserved.

About Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Security | Contact Us


Home - HotelGuides.com US Hotels Canada Hotels Hotels in other countries View, change, or cancel my reservations Customer Service Our Better Business Bureau rating is A+ Hotel Guides is Made in USA
Hotel Guides