Rated High Upper-midscale, smoke-free, full-service motel
Overlooks the harbor
2 floors, 67 rooms
Free shuttle to beach
Heated outdoor swimming pool - exercise room
Restaurant - lounge
Free WiFi
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Jun 2017
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 286 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated Very High Midscale, smoke-free, eco-freindly motel near beach
Next to Sag Harbor golf course
Single-story, 14 rooms and suites
No swimming pool
Microwave and refrigerator in every room
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly motel - allows small pets only - no pet fee. - Feb 2016
Most Recent HotelGuides Review
"This motel was absolutely amazing. It was extremely quiet. The heater was small but eventually heated up the room, and the furnishings were tasteful. Don't mind the large dog in the office; he's nice. Definitely a good place to stay.2017-03-02"
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 101 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated Very High Luxury, smoke-free, full-service hotel
3 floors, 22 rooms - elevator
Heated outdoor swimming pool - exercise room
Restaurant - lounge
Free hot breakfast buffet
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly hotel - allows pets up to 30 pounds - $35 per night fee for each pet. - Mar 2016
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 145 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated Very High Upscale, smoke-free bed and breakfast inn
Near Peconic River and Shelter Island Country Club
2 floors, 4 rooms - no elevator
No swimming pool
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Nov 2014
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 247 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated Average Midscale, full-service, beachfront motel
Near Shelter Island Country Club
2 floors, 20 rooms - no elevator
Seasonal motel - closed during winter
No swimming pool
Restaurant
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly motel - $150 per stay pet fee. - Oct 2014
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 124 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
6 milesMill House Inn East Hampton31 North Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937 6 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated Average Luxury, smoke-free, downtown, bed and breakfast inn
2 miles from East Hampton Main Beach
2 floors, 10 rooms and suites - no elevator
No swimming pool
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly bed and breakfast inn - allows dogs only - $60 per night fee for each dog. - Jan 2018
7 milesEast Hampton House226 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937 7 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated Average Midscale, smoke-free, highway motel
Near downtown East Hampton
2 floors, 52 rooms - no elevator
Heated outdoor swimming pool - exercise room
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Feb 2016
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 112 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
7 milesJourney Hotel East Hampton490 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937 7 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated Average Luxury, smoke-free motel 1.5 miles from beach
2 floors, 25 rooms and suites - no elevator
Outdoor swimming pool
Lounge
Free continental breakfast
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Jan 2018
Note: This hotel charges a resort fee of $40 per night - includes parking, Internet access, and bikes.
Rated High Luxury, smoke-free, beachfront motel
3 buildings - 1, 2, and 2 floors - no elevator
Seasonal motel - closed during winter
Outdoor swimming pool open in summer - exercise room
Free continental breakfast
Pet friendly motel - allows pets up to 50 pounds in 2 pet rooms, 1 pet per room - pets must remain in pet carrier or cage - $75 per stay pet fee. - May 2017
Note: This hotel charges a resort fee of $15 per night - includes parking and Internet access.
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 774 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated Average Midscale, smoke-free, Long Island motel
Near Southhampton Golf Club
Single-story, 13 rooms and suites
Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Jan 2015
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 101 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
10 milesSouthampton Inn91 Hill Street, Southampton, NY 11968 10 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated Average Midscale, smoke-free motel on Long Island
2 miles from Cooper's Beach
2 floors, 90 rooms - no elevator - AAA 3 Diamonds
Free shuttle to Cooper's Beach in summer
Heated outdoor swimming pool open in summer
Tennis court
Restaurant
Restaurant open for breakfast only
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly motel - $50 per night pet fee. - Aug 2014
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 325 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated High Midscale, smoke-free, beachfront suites
Long sand walkway to beach
2 floors, 35 studio and 2-bedroom suites
Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
Kitchen in every suite
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Nov 2015
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 79 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
18 milesRuschmeyer's Hotel Montauk161 Second House Road, Montauk, NY 11945 18 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated Average Luxury, smoke-free cabins on west side of Fort Pond
Near downtown
19 cabins
Seasonal cabins - closed during winter
No swimming pool
Restaurant - lounge
Restaurant open for dinner only
Free continental breakfast
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly cabins - $75 per night fee for each pet. - Aug 2017
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 4 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
18 milesSole East Resort Montauk90 Second House Road, Montauk, NY 11954 18 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated High Luxury, smoke-free, full-service resort near beach
2 floors; 60 rooms, 7 suites - no elevator
Seasonal hotel - closed during winter
Heated outdoor swimming pool
Restaurant - lounge - pool side bar
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly resort - $200 per stay pet fee. - Nov 2015
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 428 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated Average Midscale, smoke-free motel
Across the street from the beach
2 floors, 26 rooms and suites - no elevator
Seasonal hotel - closed during winter
No swimming pool
Free WiFi
Limited free parking
Pet friendly motel - $200 per stay fee for each pet. - Nov 2015
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 67 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
18 milesMontauk Blue Hotel108 South Emerson Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954 18 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated High Midscale, smoke-free, beachfront motel
2 floors, 82 rooms - elevator
Seasonal hotel - closed during winter
Heated indoor swimming pool
Microwave and refrigerator in every room
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Nov 2015
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 393 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated Very High Midscale, smoke-free motel near Montauk Harbor
Also near beach
2 floors, 33 rooms and suites - no elevator
Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly motel - $125 per stay pet fee. - Aug 2017
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 630 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
19 milesMontauk Yacht Club Hotel32 Star Island Road, Montauk, NY 11954 19 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated High Upscale, smoke-free, full-service, Long Island hotel
Surrounded by Lake Montauk - near Suffolk County Parkland
3 buildings - 2 floors, 107 rooms - no elevator
Seasonal hotel - closed during winter
Free shuttle to local attractions
Indoor swimming pool - outdoor pool - exercise room
Restaurant - lounge - room service
Full-service spa
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Nov 2015
Note: This hotel charges a resort fee of $15 per night - includes parking and Internet access.
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 643 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated Very High Upscale, smoke-free, full-service hotel near waterfront
3 floors, 81 rooms and suites - elevator - AAA 4 Diamonds
No shuttle to Bradley Airport
Free shuttle to other attractions within 3-mile radius
Indoor swimming pool - outdoor pool - exercise room
Restaurant - lounge - room service
Full-service spa
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly resort - allows dogs only up to 50 pounds - $50 pet fee for 1st night - $25 fee for each night thereafter. - Apr 2016
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 832 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
20 milesHyatt Place Hotel Riverhead451 East Main Street, Riverhead, NY 11901 20 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated Very High Midscale, smoke-free hotel near downtown Riverhead
4 miles from Tanger Outlet Mall
5 floors, 100 rooms
Heated indoor swimming pool - outdoor pool
Exercise room
24-hour self-serve restaurant
Free hot breakfast buffet
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly hotel - allows pets up to 75 pounds - $75 pet fee if staying fewer than 7 nights - $175 pet fee if staying 7 nights or more. - Nov 2015
Most Recent HotelGuides Review
"A pleasant hotel stay. The room and grounds were clean, and the staff was courteous. You'll be happy if you stay here.2017-06-15"
Rated Average Cheap, smoke-free hotel near Westbrook Tanger Outlet Mall
3 floors, 44 rooms and suites - elevator
Heated outdoor swimming pool open in summer
Microwave and refrigerator in every room
Free continental breakfast
Free WiFi
Free parking - truck parking
Pet friendly hotel - allows pets up to 35 pounds, 2 pets per room - $30 per stay pet fee up to 7 nights. - Dec 2016
Most Recent HotelGuides Review
"We had a very unpleasant experience at this hotel. It was run-down, and the check-in clerk didn't smile or welcome us. The room was dated and plain had a terrible stench. When we returned from our event, it was too cold for comfortable sleeping. Breakfast was all carbs. Stay away.2015-10-06"
Rated Average Upscale, smoke-free, waterfront, full-service hotel
Overlooks Long Island Sound
3 floors, 170 rooms and suites - elevator
Heated indoor swimming poolr>
Outdoor pool open in summer
Exercise room
3 restaurants - 2 lounges - cafe
Full-service spa
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - May 2016
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 823 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
21 milesSuper 8 Hotel Old Saybrook37 Spencer Plain Road, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 21 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated Average Cheap motel
Near Westbrook Tanger Outlet Mall
2 floors, 44 rooms - no elevator
Outdoor swimming pool open in summer
Free continental breakfast
Free WiFi
Free parking - truck parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Sep 2016
Most Recent HotelGuides Review
"Easy access to Route 95. I was happy with my motel room. The bed was comfortable, but it was high off the floor. Limited TV channels. The outdoor pool was a plus.2018-08-19"
"Good motel if you need affordable rates and easy access to I-95. I've stayed here once a year for 15 years and like it. Nice, clean room and friendly staff. The pool was great.2017-08-18"
"Easy access to Route 95. Across the street from Kohl's and a supermarket, and near a good Thai restaurant and antique store. I've stayed at this motel once a year for about a decade. The pool and wireless Internet with password are great amenities.2016-08-22"
"My motel room was clean and comfortable, and the staff was friendly and courteous. My stay was fine.2016-05-23"
"I've stayed at this motel a number of times, and my experience is generally good. Not a fancy place, but it's clean and convenient to Route 95. The front desk clerks are helpful and pleasant.2016-04-21"
Rated High Midscale, smoke-free, Long Island hotel
Near Tanger Outlet Mall and Splish Splash Water Park
3 floors, 89 rooms and suites - elevator
Outdoor swimming pool open in summer - exercise room
Free hot breakfast buffet
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly hotel - allows up to medium-sized dogs only, 1 dog per room - $50 per stay pet fee. - Nov 2015
Most Recent HotelGuides Review
"Clean, comfortable room and plenty of amenities. Definitely stay at this hotel.2018-08-13"
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 226 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
22 milesGreenview Inn Riverhead1433 West Main Street, Riverhead, NY 11901 22 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated Very Low – Not Recommended Midscale, smoke-free, Long Island motel near Tanger Outlets
Also near Splish Splash Water Park
2 floors, 54 rooms - no elevator
No swimming pool
Note: No Internet access
Free parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - May 2017
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 30 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
22 milesQuality Inn Old Saybrook100 Essex Road, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 22 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated High Midscale, smoke-free, interstate hotel near I-95 at US 1
3 miles from downtown Old Saybrook
3 floors, 150 rooms - elevator
Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
Restaurant
Restaurant open for dinner only
Free continental breakfast
Free WiFi
Free parking - truck parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Dec 2016
Most Recent HotelGuides Review
"The hotel was nice and clean, and the check-in clerk was friendly and professional. Great pool. Breakfast was good, but the restaurant next door was not.2016-04-06"
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 327 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
22 milesOld Lyme Inn85 Lyme Street, Old Lyme, CT 06371 22 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated High Midscale, smoke-free bed and breakfast inn
In town of Old Lyme near I-95 at US 1
2 floors, 13 rooms - no elevator
No swimming pool
Restaurant - lounge
Full-service spa
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - May 2017
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 132 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
Rated Very High Upscale, smoke-free, all-suite, extended-stay hotel
Near Tanger Outlets
4 floors, 131 suites
Indoor swimming pool - outdoor pool - exercise room
Kitchen in every suite
Free hot breakfast buffet
Free WiFi
Free parking
Pet friendly hotel - $150 per stay pet fee + an additional $20 per night fee for each pet. - Sep 2017
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 41 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
23 milesHotel Indigo Riverhead1830 West Main Street, Riverhead, NY 11901 23 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated High Upscale, smoke-free, full-service hotel on Long Island
Near Tanger Outlet Mall and Splish Splash Water Park
2 floors, 100 rooms and suites - elevator
Outdoor swimming pool open in summer - exercise room
Restaurant - lounge - room service
Free WiFi
Free parking - truck parking
Pet friendly hotel - allows dogs only, 1 dog per room - $50 per stay pet fee. - Nov 2015
Most Recent HotelGuides Review
"The hotel room was nicely appointed, and the staff was professional and accommodating. There were a few drawbacks, like too few power outlets. There was an extension cord for the alarm clock and bedside lamp. It was worth the extra fee to have a refrigerator. The worst part of our stay was on the last day, when we saw a cockroach on the bathroom floor. Excellent meals at Bistro 72.2015-08-04"
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: Based on 564 reviewsRead Recent Reviews
23 milesHilton Garden Inn Riverhead2038 Old Country Road, Riverhead, NY 11901 23 miles from Bay Street Theatre
Rated Very High Upper-midscale, smoke-free, Long Island hotel
Near Tanger Mall and Splish Splash Water Park
3 floors, 114 rooms and suites - elevator
Heated indoor swimming pool - exercise room
Restaurant - lounge - room service
Restaurant open for breakfast and dinner only
Microwave and refrigerator in every room
Free WiFi
Free parking
Not pet friendly - no pets allowed. - Oct 2015
Most Recent HotelGuides Review
"We had an enjoyable overnight stay. I was sorry we couldn't stay longer. Definitely recommend this hotel.2015-10-05"
