Shelter Island, NY Pet-Friendly Hotels
Looking for a place to stay in Shelter Island with your pet? Then use this pet-friendly accommodations guide to learn about Shelter Island hotels and motels that allow dogs and other pets.
Hotel pet policies change frequently. To make sure your pet will be accepted by a hotel, use our free pet check service.
You may also want to visit our complete guide to all Shelter Island hotels.
Pet-Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island, NY
Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island|
35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965
Rated Low Not Recommended
Midscale, full-service, beachfront motel
Near Shelter Island Country Club
2 floors, 20 rooms - no elevatorSeasonal motel - closed during winter
No swimming pool
Free Internet in room
Pet-friendly hotel - $150 per stay pet fee. - Oct 2014